Lady
Snowblood (1973, Toshiya Fujita)
Revenge
tales in cinema are, for the most part, strikingly similar when
compared. Someone of note is wronged and, convinced that the
perpetrators must suffer punishment at all costs, dedicates
themselves to tracking down their prey with vicious cunning and
deadly seriousness, often circumventing law, which in their eyes is
an insufficient tool in ensuring the villains pay their dues. Change
any of those ingredients too much, and one is left with something
other than a revenge story. Conversely, being too rigid within the
parameters of the genre and the result is a movie which brings
nothing new to the table, not to mention that the genre itself is not
the most fertile ground for remarkably dynamic storytelling. As the
old saying goes: 'You've seen 1, you've seen them all.' Director
Toshiya Fujita and screenwriters Kazuo Kamimura and Kazuo Koike give
it their best to shake things up a bit in the adaptation of Lady
Snowblood, one of Japan's most celebrated manga books.
Yuki
Kashima (Meiki Kaji), who travels Japan under the name of Lady
Snowblood, has a single purpose in life, only one raison d'être that
keeps her going is the desire to see four gangsters murdered and sent
to the depths of hell where they belong, among them Otora Mikazuki
(Kaoru Kusuda), Banzo Takemura (Noburo Makaya) and the pseudo leader,
Gishiro Tsukamoto (Eiji Okada). Yuki's story in fact begins even
before she was born 20 years ago. It was her mother, father and big
brother who, one day while walking to their new home where her father
has received a new job as teacher, were accosted by the hoodlums, who
mistook the father for somebody else. The father and boy were quickly
dispatched, but Yuki's mother was kept for sexual pleasures, until
she got her revenge on at least one of them, but by then she had
already become pregnant. Giving birth in jail to Yuki, surrounded by
her jail mates, her mother's final breath is a wish: that Yuki grow
up to become an assassin and destroy the remaining gangsters who
ruined their lives.
Toshiya
Fujita's Lady Snowblood is one of those films that make some
valiant attempts at bringing the unexpected to this sort of story,
attempts which end up being the film's major strengths, all the while
giving in to some of the familiar tropes of the genres, said
qualities being the film's weaker aspects. To begin, let us get the
negatives out of the way before giving the film its due credit where
deserved.
It
is a little bit odd to consider that in this six film marathon, not
only were two of the films Japanese, the other being Sword of
Vengeance, but each was a cold revenge story set in a period when
battles could still be fought with samurai blades as opposed to guns
(although Lady Snowblood transpires a much later in history
and a couple pistols make brief appearances). Comparisons between the
two shall not make up the majority of the current review, but if one
were to note yet another similarity with Sword, it is that, for some
reason, the movie stops the forward progression of the action when
already deep into the running time in order to fill in Yuki's back
story. Snowblood thankfully does not perform this little trick
multiple times (which was the case in Sword), but it remains a
no no in the opinion of this movie reviewer. Unless a director or
screenwriter has a very clever, inventive way of inserting the back
story at the one-third or halfway point of a movie, then it feels
misplaced. Tell that portion of the plot before sending the viewer
into the thrust of the action. Do not engage the heart of the
journey, only to bring all that momentum to a standstill in order to
divulge some historical information. It is out of fear that an
audience might grow impatient if the actor or actress playing the
protagonist is not shown for many scenes in the case of a movie where
the back story involves episodes from the character's childhood? The
real reason remains a mystery.
Lady
Snowblood also has a great love for pointless narration.
Actually, it is not true narration given that the booming male voice
that comes and goes throughout the film does not reveal or describe a
whole lot of the story. Rather, it mostly wants to convey Yuki's
emotional and psychological state at the time of the unfolding
events. This is no better than regurgitating exactly what it
transpiring on screen, since the actress at the centre of everyone's
attention should be strong enough to convey that important
information through her dialogue, her face and her actions. Of
course, when a performance is as cold as Meiki Kaji's, maybe some
narrated explanations about who she is and how she is feeling becomes
a requirement. It is not that the actress gives a poor performance
per say, only that there really is not much there for the viewer to
latch on to. It is calculated to the tiniest detail in order for Yuki
Kashima to come across as very fitting of her nickname, Lady
Snowblood. Maybe if there was something else about her it would be
easier to empathize with the character. As it stands, we are but
watching what amounts to a machine go after a series of villains.
There are fleeting moments when she hints at something else behind
the cold facade, and those moments are much appreciated, but overall
the protagonist is simply not very interesting. She looks amazing
though, and by that it is not her natural good looks which are being
referred to (although even in that respect she does look amazing)
but the costumes and makeup, which lend her a geisha-like aura, what
with the incredibly pale face and perfect fitting, handsomely
designed kimono. She is a Luc Besson heroine, only she speaks
Japanese and kills with a blade instead of a gun.
Where
the film earns critical points for doing things well is in fact in
the script, which does lift it slightly above the average vengeance
story. For one, the handling of the villains Yuki is after is very
smart and in some cases unexpected. The first of her victims, Banzo
Takemura, is a perfect. One might be forgiven for predicting that all
of these targets have gone on to become wealthy pigs, still stamping
on innocent folk to preserve their status as members of the feared
elite, but that is not what has happened, not at all in the case of
Banzo. This is a man who has a beautiful daughter who has to whore
herself out so that she and her father can pay the bills. So as to
not anger and shame Banzo, she pretends to be a basket merchant.
Banzo loves his daughter, but since falling on hard times has given
in to other kinds of sin (other than rape, that is): he is a severe
alcoholic and wastes too much money in the gambling rooms in town. So
rather than finding someone who is despicable because he has profited
from his previous malice, Yuki finds someone who is despicable
because he is down in the dumps, as if already beginning to pay for
his sins. Far be it from Yuki to show him pity of course...
The
script continues to impress and keep the proceedings pertinent by
revealing twists along the way. Immediately after dispatching Banzo,
Yuki learns from her contacts that the leader of the thugs, Gishiro,
is already dead, sending a shock wave through her. Here is one
bastard she will not be able to kill by her own hands. What follows
shall not be revealed in this review, but the story of what happened
to Gishiro does not end there, leading down a path which adds a rich
texture to the story. What's more, the film ensures that multiple
characters have important emotional stakes. A writer and cartoon
artist enters the fray at the midpoint whose links to Yuki's mission
are far more critical than she originally imagines, and, as icing on
the cake, Banzo's daughter goes for revenge once she learns of what
Yuki did to him. The story has a nice amount of surprises that are
honestly hard to predict. Director Fujita shows off the excellent
direction, in particular during the finale, which, in yet another
unexpected turn, occurs at a English-Victorian costume ball.
Lady
Snowblood is no perfect film, and in some respects it embraces rather annoying contrivances, but simultaneously manages to
overcome said deficiencies with some creativity in areas where one
would least expect, coming from a revenge movie.
Done here? Find out if how many limbs Bill has left after escaping Lady Snowblood's wrath. at his Movie Emporium.
Done here? Find out if how many limbs Bill has left after escaping Lady Snowblood's wrath. at his Movie Emporium.
No comments:
Post a Comment